Problem 82
Easy Geometric Probability

Two points L and M are chosen at random on a segment AB of…

Two points $L$ and $M$ are chosen at random on a segment $AB$ of length $l$. Find the probability that $L$ is closer to $M$ than to $A$.

Explanation of Method

Let $x=AL$ and $y=AM$; the point $(x,y)$ is uniform in the square $[0,l]^2$. The condition is $|x-y|\lt x$. If $M$ lies to the left of $L$ ($y\lt x$) it always holds; if $M$ lies to the right it holds when $y\lt 2x$. We describe the region and compute its area; it is easier to measure the small unfavourable triangle.

Step 1: The model

Put $A$ at $0$ and $B$ at $l$. Let $x=AL$, $y=AM$, independent and uniform on $[0,l]$: the point $(x,y)$ is uniform in the square of area $l^2$.

Step 2: The condition

$LM=|x-y|$ and $LA=x$. We need $|x-y|\lt x$:

So the favourable region is $\{y\lt 2x\}$ — everything to the right of the line $y=2x$.

$\tfrac l2$ $l$ $l$ $x=AL$ $y=AM$ $y=2x$
  • $L$ is closer to $M$ than to $A$: $y\lt 2x$
The unfavourable region is the white triangle above the line $y=2x$, with vertices $(0,0)$, $(0,l)$, $(\tfrac l2,l)$.

Step 3: The area

The unfavourable region $\{y\ge 2x\}$ is the triangle with vertices $(0,0)$, $(0,l)$, $(\frac l2,l)$, of area $\frac12\cdot\frac l2\cdot l = \frac{l^2}4$.

\[ \boxed{P = 1-\frac{l^2/4}{l^2} = \frac34.} \]

Step 4: Intuition

$L$ is farther from $M$ than from $A$ only when $M$ lies beyond the point $2x$, i.e. $M$ is to the right of $L$ at a distance greater than $AL$. That requires $L$ in the left half and $M$ far to the right, which happens in only a quarter of the cases.


Result

Answer
Condition$|x-y|\lt x$, i.e. $y\lt 2x$
Probability$P=3/4$