Problem 41
Medium Translational Kinematics

A train starts from a station with uniform acceleration. An…

A train starts from a station with uniform acceleration. An observer standing beside the track at the front of the train sees the first wagon pass him in $t_1 = 4\ \mathrm{s}$. How long does the 5th wagon take to pass him?

Explanation of Method

How fast the 5th wagon passes an observer.

Step 1: When has the $n$-th wagon passed?

Let each wagon have length $l$. The train starts from rest, so after time $t$ it has moved $\tfrac12 a t^2$. The first $n$ wagons have passed the observer when the train has moved $nl$:

\[ nl = \tfrac12 a t_n^2, \]

\[ l = \tfrac12 a t_1^2. \]

Dividing the two equations: $\frac{t_n^2}{t_1^2} = n \;\Longrightarrow\; t_n = t_1\sqrt n$.

Step 2: Time for the $n$-th wagon alone

The $n$-th wagon passes between the moments $t_{n-1}$ (first $n-1$ wagons gone) and $t_n$: $\Delta t_n = t_n - t_{n-1} = t_1\left(\sqrt n - \sqrt{n-1}\right)$.

Step 3: The 5th wagon

\[ \Delta t_5 = 4\ \mathrm{s} \cdot \left(\sqrt5 - \sqrt4\right) = 4 \cdot (2.236 - 2)\ \mathrm{s}. \]

\[\Delta t_5 = 4(\sqrt5 - 2)\ \mathrm{s} \approx 0.94\ \mathrm{s}\]

Check

$ t_4 = 4\sqrt4 = 8\ \mathrm{s}, \quad t_5 = 4\sqrt5 \approx 8.944\ \mathrm{s} $

$ t_5 - t_4 \approx 0.944\ \mathrm{s}\ \checkmark $

$1$ $2$ $3$ $4$ $5$ $0$ $4$ $5.66$ $6.93$ $8$ $8.94$ $4.00\ \mathrm{s}$ $1.66\ \mathrm{s}$ $1.27\ \mathrm{s}$ $1.07$ $0.94\ \mathrm{s}$ $t\ (\mathrm{s})$ $\text{wagon } n \text{ has passed at } t_n = t_1\sqrt n:\ \ 4,\ 5.66,\ 6.93,\ 8,\ 8.94\ \mathrm{s}$
Time line to scale: each coloured block is the time one wagon takes to pass the observer. The train keeps speeding up, so each wagon passes faster than the one before; the 5th takes only 0.94 s.

Result

\[\boxed{\,\Delta t_5 = 4(\sqrt5 - 2)\ \mathrm{s} \approx 0.94\ \mathrm{s}\,}\]

Remark

About the two original solutions. The attachment had two solutions with different answers. The second one (0.94 s) is correct. The first one (1.07 s) used $t_4 = \sqrt3\,t_1$ and $t_5 = 2t_1$, i.e. the moments when 3 and 4 wagons had passed, so it actually found the time of the 4th wagon: $4(2 - \sqrt3) = \tfrac{4}{2 + \sqrt3} \approx 1.07\ \mathrm{s}$.