Problem 177
Medium Conics and Transformations

For the family λ x^2-3xy+y^2+λ x+3=0 , determine λ so that…

For the family $\lambda x^2-3xy+y^2+\lambda x+3=0$, determine $\lambda$ so that the equation represents: $1^\circ$ ellipses (real or imaginary); $2^\circ$ hyperbolas; $3^\circ$ a parabola; $4^\circ$ a point; $5^\circ$ a pair of intersecting lines; $6^\circ$ a pair of parallel lines.

Explanation of Method

Classifying a one-parameter family of conics by the signs of δ and Δ.

Step 1: Invariants

\[ \delta=\lambda-\tfrac94,\qquad \Delta=\begin{vmatrix}\lambda&-\tfrac32&\tfrac\lambda2\\-\tfrac32&1&0\\\tfrac\lambda2&0&3\end{vmatrix}=-\frac{\lambda^2}{4}+3\lambda-\frac{27}4=-\frac{(\lambda-3)(\lambda-9)}{4}. \]

Step 2: Classification

TypeCondition$\lambda$
real ellipses$\delta\gt 0,\ A\Delta\lt 0$$\tfrac94\lt \lambda\lt 3$ or $\lambda\gt 9$
imaginary ellipses$\delta\gt 0,\ A\Delta\gt 0$$3\lt \lambda\lt 9$
hyperbolas$\delta\lt 0$ ($\Delta\ne0$ automatically)$\lambda\lt \tfrac94$
parabola$\delta=0,\ \Delta=-\tfrac{81}{64}\ne0$$\lambda=\tfrac94$
point$\delta\gt 0,\ \Delta=0$$\lambda=3$ or $\lambda=9$
intersecting lines$\delta\lt 0,\ \Delta=0$none
parallel lines$\delta=0,\ \Delta=0$none

Since $A=\lambda\gt 0$ on the whole ellipse range, the sign test $A\Delta\lt 0$ reduces to $\Delta\lt 0$.

Step 3: The two points

$\lambda=3$: the centre equations $6x-3y+3=0$ and $-3x+2y=0$ give $(-2,-3)$, and $F(-2,-3)=12-18+9-6+3=0$. Since $\delta\gt 0$, the quadratic form is definite. The conic is therefore the single real point $(-2,-3)$: two complex-conjugate lines meet there.

$\lambda=9$: in the same way the point is $\left(-\tfrac23,-1\right)$, with $F=4-2+1-6+3=0$.

\[\lambda=3:\ \{(-2,-3)\},\qquad \lambda=9:\ \left\{\left(-\tfrac23,-1\right)\right\}\]

λ hyperbolas real ellipses imaginary ellipses real ellipses 9/4 parabola 3 point 9 point 0
Type of $\lambda x^2-3xy+y^2+\lambda x+3=0$ along the $\lambda$-axis (scale not uniform). Pairs of lines (intersecting or parallel) never occur.

Result

\[\boxed{\,\lambda=3:\ \{(-2,-3)\},\qquad \lambda=9:\ \left\{\left(-\tfrac23,-1\right)\right\}\,}\]

Remark

Clarification: the source's wording in $4^\circ$ (“point or two real lines”, and the condition $\Delta/A\lt 0$) is imprecise. With $\delta\gt 0$ and $\Delta=0$ the curve is always exactly one real point, never two real lines. For $5^\circ$ and $6^\circ$ there is no solution: $\Delta=0$ forces $\lambda\in\{3,9\}$, where $\delta\gt 0$, and $\delta=0$ forces $\lambda=\tfrac94$, where $\Delta\ne0$.