Problem 139
Medium Triple Products and Volume

Let vec s_1,...,vec s_4 be the outward normals of the faces…

Let $\vec s_1,\dots,\vec s_4$ be the outward normals of the faces of a tetrahedron, with $|\vec s_i|$ equal to the area of the face. Prove that $\vec s_1+\vec s_2+\vec s_3+\vec s_4=\vec 0$.

Explanation of Method

The outward face-area vectors of a tetrahedron sum to zero.

Step 1: The four face vectors

Take $A$ as origin, $\vec p=\overrightarrow{AB}$, $\vec q=\overrightarrow{AC}$, $\vec r=\overrightarrow{AD}$, with $[\vec p,\vec q,\vec r]\gt0$ (otherwise rename $B\leftrightarrow C$). The vector $\vec p\times\vec q$ makes $(\vec p\times\vec q)\cdot\vec r\gt0$, i.e. it points towards $D$, into the solid. The outward vector of face $ABC$ is therefore $-\tfrac12\vec p\times\vec q$, and so on:

FaceOpposite vertexOutward area vector
$BCD$$A$$\vec s_1=\tfrac12(\vec q-\vec p)\times(\vec r-\vec p)=\tfrac12(\vec q\times\vec r+\vec r\times\vec p+\vec p\times\vec q)$
$ACD$$B$$\vec s_2=-\tfrac12\,\vec q\times\vec r$
$ABD$$C$$\vec s_3=-\tfrac12\,\vec r\times\vec p$
$ABC$$D$$\vec s_4=-\tfrac12\,\vec p\times\vec q$

Check for $\vec s_1$: the direction from face $BCD$ towards $A$ is $-\vec p$, and $\vec s_1\cdot(-\vec p)=-\tfrac12[\vec q,\vec r,\vec p]\lt0$. So $\vec s_1$ points away from $A$, i.e. outward $\checkmark$

Step 2: Sum

\[ \vec s_1+\vec s_2+\vec s_3+\vec s_4=\tfrac12(\vec q\times\vec r+\vec r\times\vec p+\vec p\times\vec q)-\tfrac12(\vec q\times\vec r+\vec r\times\vec p+\vec p\times\vec q)=\vec 0. \]

\[\vec s_1+\vec s_2+\vec s_3+\vec s_4=\vec 0\qquad\blacksquare\]

Step 3: Projection argument

For any unit vector $\hat e$, $\hat e\cdot\vec s_i$ is the signed area of the projection of face $i$ onto a plane perpendicular to $\hat e$. The faces seen "from the front" and "from the back" cover the same projected region of the closed solid, so these signed areas cancel. Since $\hat e$ is arbitrary, the sum is $\vec 0$.

$\vec s_1$ $\vec s_2$ $\vec s_3$ $\vec s_4$ $A$ $B$ $C$ $D$
Outward face vectors (length proportional to the face area) attached at the face centroids; $\vec s_1$ belongs to face $BCD$ (opposite $A$), etc. Their sum is $\vec 0$.

Result

\[\boxed{\,\vec s_1+\vec s_2+\vec s_3+\vec s_4=\vec 0\qquad\blacksquare\,}\]

Remark

Correction of signs. The source takes $+\tfrac12\vec p\times\vec q$ etc. as outward for the three faces through $A$ and calls $(\vec q-\vec p)\times(\vec r-\vec p)$ inward for $BCD$. For a right-handed $\vec p,\vec q,\vec r$ all four of these orientations are reversed. The total is still $\vec 0$, because flipping all four vectors does not change a zero sum, so the conclusion stands.