Double Integral 89
Medium Changing the Order of Integration

Find F'(t), where: F(t) = double integral over

Find $F'(t)$, where: $$ F(t) = \iint_{[0,t]\times[0,t]} e^{tx/y^2}\,dx\,dy, \qquad t>0. $$

Explanation of Method

Before differentiating $F(t)$, it must first be checked that $F(t)$ is actually a finite, well-defined function of $t$ — differentiation under the integral sign (Leibniz's rule) presumes this. Examining the integrand near $y=0$ shows that this integral is divergent for every $t>0$, so $F(t)$ is not a real-valued function and $F'(t)$ does not exist. This is worked out honestly below, rather than manipulating a formally divergent expression.

  1. Isolate the behavior of the integrand as $y\to0^+$ for fixed $x>0$.
  2. Show the resulting one-dimensional integral in $y$ diverges to $+\infty$.
  3. Conclude that $F(t)\equiv+\infty$ for every $t>0$, so $F$ is not differentiable.

Step 1 · Examine the integrand near $y=0$

Fix $t>0$ and any $x\in(0,t]$. As $y\to0^+$, the exponent $\dfrac{tx}{y^2}\to+\infty$ (since $t>0$ and $x>0$), and therefore:

$$ e^{tx/y^2} \longrightarrow +\infty \quad\text{as } y\to0^+, $$

and it does so faster than any power of $\dfrac1y$ — the exponential blow-up dominates any algebraic decay one might hope to offset it with.

Step 2 · Show the inner integral diverges

For fixed $x\in(0,t]$, consider the inner integral with respect to $y$:

$$ \int_0^t e^{tx/y^2}\,dy. $$

Since $e^{tx/y^2}>1$ for all $y\in(0,t]$ (the exponent is positive), and $e^{tx/y^2}\to+\infty$ non-integrably as $y\to0^+$ (it is not dominated by any integrable function near $y=0$; indeed for any $M$, $e^{tx/y^2}>M$ once $y<\sqrt{tx/\ln M}$, an interval of positive length), the integral diverges:

$$ \int_0^t e^{tx/y^2}\,dy = +\infty \qquad \text{for every fixed } x\in(0,t]. $$

Step 3 · Conclude that $F(t)$ is not finite

Since the inner integral is already $+\infty$ for (almost) every $x\in[0,t]$, the double integral diverges as well:

$$ F(t) = \int_0^t\left(\int_0^t e^{tx/y^2}\,dy\right)dx = +\infty \qquad \text{for every } t>0. $$

Numerically, truncating the $y$-integration away from $0$ confirms explosive, non-convergent growth: cutting off at $y\geqslant0.1$ already gives a partial value of order $10^{38}$ (for $t=1$), and the partial values grow without bound as the cutoff shrinks toward $0$.


Additional Notes

Result

The integral diverges for every $t>0$, so $F$ is not a well-defined real function and $F'(t)$ does not exist:

$$ F(t) = \iint_{[0,t]\times[0,t]} e^{tx/y^2}\,dx\,dy = +\infty \quad \text{for all } t>0. $$