Problem 196
Easy Limits and Functions

Determine the points of discontinuity of f(z)=(tanh z)/(z^2+1)

Determine the points of discontinuity of $\ f(z)=\dfrac{\tanh z}{z^2+1}$.

Explanation of Method

Write $\tanh z=\sinh z/\cosh z$, so $f(z)=\sinh z\big/\!\left[\cosh z\,(z^2+1)\right]$ fails to be defined where $\cosh z=0$ or $z^2+1=0$. Solve both, then check whether $\sinh z$ vanishes at any of those points (which would make the singularity removable).

Step 1 · Zeros of $\cosh z$

$$ \cosh z=0\iff e^{2z}=-1=e^{i\pi}\iff z=\frac{i\pi(2n+1)}2,\quad n\in\mathbb Z $$

i.e. $z\in\left\{\ldots,-\tfrac{3i\pi}2,-\tfrac{i\pi}2,\tfrac{i\pi}2,\tfrac{3i\pi}2,\ldots\right\}$, all purely imaginary.

Step 2 · Zeros of $z^2+1$

$$ z^2+1=0\iff z=\pm i $$

Step 3 · Check the numerator at the $\cosh z$ zeros

At $z_n=i\pi(n+\tfrac12)$, using $e^{i\pi(n+1/2)}=(-1)^ni$: $$ \sinh z_n=\frac{e^{z_n}-e^{-z_n}}2=\frac{(-1)^ni-(-1)^n(-i)}2=(-1)^ni\neq0 $$ so none of these poles is removable.

Step 4 · Check the numerator at $z=\pm i$

$$ \sinh(i)=\frac{e^i-e^{-i}}2=i\sin1\neq0,\qquad \sinh(-i)=-i\sin1\neq0 $$

Verified numerically: $\sinh(i)\approx0.8415i=i\sin(1)$. Neither is removable.

Step 5 · No overlap between the two zero-sets

If $i=\frac{i\pi(2n+1)}2$ for some integer $n$, then $2n+1=\frac2\pi\approx0.637$, not an odd integer — contradiction. So $\pm i$ never coincide with a zero of $\cosh z$, and all poles listed below are genuinely distinct, each simple (order 1, since every zero found is simple in both factors).

Result

$$ f\text{ has simple poles at }z=\pm i\ \text{and at }z=\frac{i\pi(2n+1)}2\ (n\in\mathbb Z) $$

The pole set splits cleanly into two independent families — the two isolated poles contributed by the algebraic factor $z^2+1$, and the infinite arithmetic progression along the imaginary axis contributed by $\cosh z=0$ — and Step 5 confirms they never collide.