Problem 573
Hard Tangents, Normals, and Asymptotes

Find the length of the tangent, the length of the normal

Find the length of the tangent, the length of the normal, the subtangent, and the subnormal of the curve $x=a(2\cos t-\cos 2t),\ y=a(2\sin t-\sin 2t)$.

Explanation of Method

Sum-to-product identities collapse both velocity components to a single shared factor.

Step 1: The four formulas

With $y_x'=\dot y/\dot x$ and $dx/dy=\dot x/\dot y$: \[T = y\sqrt{1+\left(\tfrac{dx}{dy}\right)^2}, \quad N = y\sqrt{1+(y_x')^2}, \quad S_T = \frac{y}{y_x'}, \quad S_N = y\,y_x'.\]

Step 2: Compute $\dot x,\dot y$ and simplify

\[ \dot x = 2a(\sin 2t-\sin t) = 4a\cos\frac{3t}2\sin\frac t2, \qquad \dot y = 2a(\cos t-\cos 2t) = 4a\sin\frac{3t}2\sin\frac t2, \tag{1} \] using $\sin2t-\sin t=2\cos\frac{3t}2\sin\frac t2$ and $\cos t-\cos2t=2\sin\frac{3t}2\sin\frac t2$.

Step 3: The slope

\[ y_x' = \frac{\dot y}{\dot x} = \frac{\sin\dfrac{3t}2}{\cos\dfrac{3t}2} = \tan\frac{3t}2, \qquad \frac{dx}{dy} = \cot\frac{3t}2. \tag{2} \]

Step 4: Simplify $y$

\[ y = a(2\sin t-\sin2t) = 2a\sin t(1-\cos t) = 2a\cdot2\sin\frac t2\cos\frac t2\cdot2\sin^2\frac t2 = 8a\sin^3\frac t2\cos\frac t2. \tag{3} \]

Step 5: Tangent length $T$ and normal length $N$

Using $1+\cot^2\frac{3t}2=1/\sin^2\frac{3t}2$, $1+\tan^2\frac{3t}2=1/\cos^2\frac{3t}2$, and $\sin\frac{3t}2=\sin\frac t2\!\left(3-4\sin^2\frac t2\right)$, $\cos\frac{3t}2=\cos\frac t2\!\left(4\cos^2\frac t2-3\right)$:

\[ T = \frac{y}{\left|\sin\dfrac{3t}2\right|} = \frac{8a\sin^2\dfrac t2\cos\dfrac t2}{\left|3-4\sin^2\dfrac t2\right|}, \qquad N = \frac{y}{\left|\cos\dfrac{3t}2\right|} = \frac{8a\sin^3\dfrac t2}{\left|4\cos^2\dfrac t2-3\right|}. \tag{4} \]

Step 6: Subtangent $S_T$ and subnormal $S_N$

\[ S_T = y\cot\frac{3t}2 = 8a\sin^3\frac t2\cos\frac t2\cdot\frac{\cos\dfrac{3t}2}{\sin\dfrac{3t}2}, \qquad S_N = y\tan\frac{3t}2 = 8a\sin^3\frac t2\cos\frac t2\cdot\frac{\sin\dfrac{3t}2}{\cos\dfrac{3t}2}. \tag{5} \]

Step 7: Verification

\[a=1,\ t=0.7\text{: all four closed forms match direct numerical differentiation of }x(t),y(t)\text{ to 10+ significant figures}\ \checkmark\]


Result

Final answer:

\[\boxed{\,\begin{aligned} T &= \frac{8a\sin^2\dfrac t2\cos\dfrac t2}{\left|3-4\sin^2\dfrac t2\right|}, & N &= \frac{8a\sin^3\dfrac t2}{\left|4\cos^2\dfrac t2-3\right|}, \\[8pt] S_T &= a(2\sin t-\sin2t)\cot\dfrac{3t}2, & S_N &= a(2\sin t-\sin2t)\tan\dfrac{3t}2. \end{aligned}\,}\]